My house mate some months ago introduced me to a group of Roman Catholics, and to be honest, before that I did not really engage much with Roman Catholics and their primary sources. Sure, I am Reformed, sure I am a professing, confessional and systematic TULIP man, sure I am convinced of the Doctrines of Grace from the Bible primarily, sure the thing that gets me out of bed every day is the sheer holiness and omni transcendence of God but I never really engaged with primary Roman Catholic sources before that. Even though I was thoroughly convinced of my positions from holy Writ (with the exception of the “rock” passage of Mt 16; but God ordained it that I dealt with it in my exegesis at bible college), I never have dealt with their texts in the way I have done with Jehovah’s Witnesses, the Mormons, and the Muslims.
So, when Roman Catholicism was portrayed as this monolithic, age transcending Church, with billions of followers and an unbroken lineage/tradition to Jesus and Peter themselves, a novice like myself was actually quite intimidated. Because what Catholics have the tendency to do is just “fact dump” on you until you give up, or give in. Or what they do is so theologically load terms such as “tradition” or “Eucharist”, “real presence” that the Church Fathers use so that when we Protestants take to their writings are intimidated by the Fathers because they are often portrayed as being proto-Catholic (and that, by implication, even us Protestants have this idea that the Reformation in 1517 was somewhat of an anarchist movement, rather than a return to historical Christianity- just read Calvin). What I ended up doing was stopping, thinking and considering the theological and historical landscape. And what I found after reading countless pages of catechisms, councils and Vatican sanctioned books was that the very core element of biblical Christianity was denied at every corner; the sufficiency of the Person and work of God for every aspect of the Christian’s life.
Now, Catholics would deny this (and Catholic friends of mine do), They say that they believe the Bible is authoritative, but that’s not the question- the question is; is the Bible sufficient? Protestants say YES. But what I find even more awkward than that is they deny the Person and work of Christ. Catholics would again say that they don’t. But to respond to that, I am reminded of a quote “there are two ways to deny something; either by saying ‘I don’t believe it’, or by adding to it.” A person may profess they believe in marriage, but they don’t if they are going to brothels or just by glancing at other people lustfully. Even though they heartily profess soberly to marriage, they practically deny it by how they live. This is the case with the Catholics. They on one hand profess the person of Christ and His life, death, resurrection and post-resurrection ministry, but then they completely nullify it by adding to it with Mary, the Saints, priests, the Mass, infant baptism etc. If you’ve read any Catholic catechism, you see the contradictions quite blatantly. And it’s sad that they don’t even notice the contradictory statements from their mouths/catechisms.
So, yes, as a Protestant, at the end of the day- all I want is God. In fact, all I need is God. I will not settle for anything less, even though it is buttered up with tradition and incredible language. We could spend a while talking about epistemological methodology and axiomatic principles, but the heart of the matter is the heart, and as a sinful kid, my confession (as un-eloquant as it is) is that “I want God. God is enough. God will get me through. God is sufficient for ALL my needs”. My sins are real, my temptations are real, my frailties are real and my fears are real. So, to have 24/7, no middle-people, Christ centred, cross based access to God the Father is the most glorious reality. I do not need Mary, I do not need a priest. I have Jesus.
“Since then we have a great high priest who has passed through the heavens, Jesus, the Son of God, let us hold fast our confession. For we do not have a high priest who is unable to sympathize with our weaknesses, but one who in every respect has been tempted as we are, yet without sin. Let us then with confidence draw near to the throne of grace, that we may receive mercy and find grace to help in time of need.”- Heb 4:14-16 (ESV)
And I can know God personally through His Word. I do not need the Magesterium, I do not need anything else the Roman “church” offers me. All I need is Scripture- where God has perfectly and sufficiently revealed the biggest realities to me; who He is, what He wants, what He has done and how much He loves His people.
And to be honest, after reading countless pages of Catholic literature, I have no hope from any of it, because I can get, and have direct access to the Sovereign God who listens through the one Priest (Jesus Christ) who sympathises with my weaknesses on the basis of His perfect, one off, sufficient death and resurrection for my sins. I have no need for anyone or anything else than the Person of God and His word. Because He is sufficient.
-Wilkins
Ps: A reliance on the sufficiency of God’s work and word is the practical application of God’s attribute of self sufficiency (aesity).